Which Halloween Candies are More Trick than Treat?

Written By: Gloria Tsang, RD

Title: Founding Registered Dietitian

Alumni: University of British Columbia

Last Updated on:

Halloween is the one night of the year when all kids (young and old) are focused on candy. We all know it’s not health food, but the truth is that not all candies are created equal – even if they look and taste similar. So how do you know which candies will cause the least damage to the ghouls and goblins in your neighborhood this Halloween?

With big differences in calories, sugar, and quality of ingredients used, the fact is, choosing the right candy can reduce the health impact of your kid’s trick-or-treat haul.  None of them are exactly good for you, of course, but we’ve done some close analysis of 20 popular Halloween candies to see which options are best from a nutrition perspective. All of our analysis was based on Halloween-sized (“fun-sized”) versions of the candy.

Halloween Candy Picks and Pans

For Peanut Fans: PayDay beats Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups

Based on the argument that peanut fans love real peanuts, PayDay is the clear winner here. Both bars have similar calories and sugar, but PayDay is the only candy we examined not to list sugar as the first ingredient. Instead, peanuts are found in the number-one spot. The Reese’s Cups also contain polyglycerol polyricinoleate (PGPR), a commercial emulsifier used to reduce the amount of cocoa butter required and reduce manufacturing costs.

For Wafer Fans: Kit Kat beats Twix

They’re similar in calories and sugar (and both include PGPR), but Twix’s ingredient list is surprisingly long. Even more surprising? Twix is marketed as a biscuit topped with caramel and chocolate, but there’s no caramel on the ingredient list. Instead, the caramel is likely made from solid oil with flavorings.

For Mini-Candy Fans: M&Ms beat Skittles

Both of these shiny mini-candies contain artificial colorings, wax, and a super-long list of ingredients. Hello, Yellow 5 and Red 40! M&Ms at least offer a tiny amount of calcium and protein instead of a sugar rush – they have about 10% less sugar than Skittles.

For Nougat Fans: Baby Ruth beats Snickers

Unfortunately, there’s no real winner here – we found partially hydrogenated oil on Snickers’ ingredient list, while Baby Ruth has high-fructose corn syrup and the preservative TBHQ. In this case, Snickers loses out simply because the portion is larger, leaving room for 50% more calories.

For Coconut Fans: Mounds beats Almond Joy

Mounds uses semi-sweet instead of milk chocolate, which means the chocolate has a higher concentration of cocoa solids and less sugar. Mounds also has a shorter ingredient list, and skips the partially hydrogenated oil found in Almond Joy.

For Straight-Up Chocolate Fans: 3 Musketeers beats Hershey’s Milk Chocolate

For those looking for a straight chocolate taste, these choices offer similar calories. 3 Musketeers wins partly because it skips the sneaky PGPR found in the Hershey’s bar. But its main winning feature is that it was unique among the candies we surveyed in actually including real cocoa powder – a great item to see on the ingredient list.

For Bite-Size Chocolate Fans: Whoppers beat Milk Duds

Whoppers are crunchy, while Milk Duds are incredibly chewy and will stick to your (or your kid’s) teeth, so they’re a no-no for anyone with dental issues. Plus, the Whoppers serving is significantly smaller (6.83 g compared to 12 g for Milk Duds), which saves about 22 calories.

The Bottom Line

Of course, no matter which Halloween candies you give out, you can’t control what comes home in your child’s trick-or-treat bag. Regardless of which treats they bring home, limit them to eating two or three small treats at a time so they can enjoy their haul without gorging themselves (or even making themselves sick).

Nutrition 101

candy, chocolate, grocery aisle, halloween, kid's nutrition, seasonal celebrations


What type of ground sugar do you use in cooking most often?

Easy Ideas for Adding Soy to Your Diet

Harvard versus USDA: Whose Plate Wins?

Leave a Comment